My first was Lego: Indiana Jones. I’ve only completed Lego games 100% so I suppose that is also my proudest since I barely used any walkthroughs to find all the treasures.

I don't think I ever completed a game I need to check. Without DLC I think Tomb Raider Legend 360.

First I don't even remember.. lol.

Probably one of my N64 games way back when.

Proudest, uh.. maybe when I hit RR11 in Dark Age of Camelot. It took a lot for me to get that and I worked really, really hard for it.

My First one i think was TMNT arcade a long time ago on NES i guess it wasnt my proudest moment but it was totally awesome.

In terms of achievements, I'd have to say Dragon Age. It's one of the very few games I've actually felt the need to purchase DLC for, just so I could have some new segment of it to play because I loved it so much. And it's also the one I have the most completed achievements of so far (not quite 100%, but I might still attempt that in the future).

My first and only two games I've finished were Cod(WAW) and Saints Row 2. Although I didn't finish the achievements just the story line. I don't think I've ever finished achievements on any game.

Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time: Master Quest

And the only game that I've 100% on the xbox is Keflings *embarassed*

I did first completed game with like achievements... If we are talking first game ever then I have NO idea lol. Probably something for the ps2 because my older gaming was always sharing it with someone else. So while we may have completed it I was never on my own.